Movie Matchups: Batman Begins vs. The Shadow (1994)

It turns out that the film that restored dignity to the Batman franchise has the exact same story as a failed adaptation of a 1930s radio show. I’m talking about 2005’s Batman Begins and 1994’s underrated action film, The Shadow.

Batman Begins has a lot in common with The Shadow.Think about it. A rich guy spends years in an Asian country learning skills to fight crime by hiding in the shadows. He then faces a villain with the same skills as him who threatens to destroy the city the hero protects. Plus, both of these films are inspired by radio shows and comics dating back to the 1930s and 1940s.

Let’s find out what similarities lurk in the heart of Batman Begins and The Shadow.

Similarities

First, I’ll list all of the things these films have in common and then I’ll dive into them more.

  • The hero spends seven years training in Asia.
  • He has a secret identity.
  • He changes his voice when he’s in disguise.
  • The hero and villain received the same special training.
  • The hero is good friends with the chief (or future chief) of police.
  • The supporting cast is filled with famous actors who almost all give memorable performances.
  • The hero disappears while someone is trying to talk to him.
  • His true identity is discovered by the film’s love interest.
  • He has a loyal servant.
  • The villain tells the hero he “never learned” to do learn an essential skill, but the hero finally learns it in the end.
  • The hero calls for help when he’s in danger of being killed.
  • The villain’s plan is to destroy a metropolitan city, just as has been done centuries before.

Seven Years in Tibet

The hero disappears for seven years to learn mysterious arts in China before returning to his hometown in the United States. Lamont Cranston learns how to cloud people’s minds to disguise himself and appear invisible to his opponents. He then returns to New York City ready to fight crime. Bruce Wayne runs away and spends years gaining new skills, such as the ability to hide in the shadows and do other things that help him fight crime upon his return to Gotham City.

Secret Identity

Lamont Cranston pretends to be a socialite to conceal his true identity.The hero hides his identity as a crime fighter behind a façade of a socialite. Cranston frequents a nightclub to give the appearance that he’s an aimless playboy with nothing better to do with his time. Wayne makes himself a joke by clubbing at night and making a scene whenever possible.

Friends with Police Chief

Sgt. (and then Lt.) Gordon works closely with the Batman.The hero is friends with the head of the police, or the man destined to become such. Cranston’s visits to the nightclub aren’t pointless. He goes there to informally meet with the police chief and learn inside information into police investigations, which helps him throw the chief off the trail of the Shadow. Wayne sneaks into Sergeant James Gordon’s office to form an alliance, and he periodically communicates valuable information to Gordon, which helps him make Lieutenant by the end of the film, on his way to Commissioner.

Voice Change

The hero uses a different voice when he’s in his alter ego. The Shadow sounds much different than Cranston’s voice, and Batman’s voice is throatier than Wayne’s.

Same Training

Bruce Wayne and Ducard have the same training.The villain has the exact same training as the hero. Shiwan Khan, the last descendant of Genghis Khan, trained under the same master as Cranston. They’re so perfectly matched that when they try to shoot each other, their bullets actually collide. A man going by the name of Ducard has the same knowledge and skills as Wayne since they both supposedly trained under a master called Ra’s Al Ghul. They’re so perfectly matched that Batman is only able to emerge victorious after many back-and-forth attempts to outsmart each other.

Stellar Supporting Cast

Tim Curry is just one of many famous actors in The Shadow's supporting cast.These two movies’ supporting casts are a who’s who of famous actors. The Shadow has Jonathan Winters, Tim Curry, Peter Boyle, and James Hong all turning in superb performances. Sir Ian McKellen is the only one whose talent is wasted in this film, playing a bumbling nuclear scientist. Batman Begins has Michael Caine, Liam Neeson, Gary Oldman, Morgan Freeman, and Tom Wilkinson stealing the show in all of their scenes. The only one who doesn’t live up to expectations is Rutger Hauer, playing a bland business leader.

Disappearing Mid-sentence

The hero has a habit of sneaking off in the middle of someone’s sentence. Cranston does it to the police chief and a woman named Margo Lane at the same time while Wayne does it to Gordon and a woman named Rachel Dawes at different times.

Love Interest Learns the Hero’s True Identity

Rachel Dawes learns that Batman is her childhood friend Bruce Wayne.A woman gets close enough to the hero to discern his true identity. Margo Lane (no relation to Lois Lane) is a gifted psychic who is overcome by the villain’s power, but she is brought back to her senses by the Shadow. She soon figures out that the Shadow and Cranston are one and the same. Rachel Dawes is an assistant to the district attorney and she gets poisoned by one of the villains and then saved by Batman. She later learns Batman is her childhood friend Bruce Wayne.

Loyal Helper

Alfred Pennyworth is Bruce Wayne's loyal servant.A loyal assistant helps the hero whenever called upon. A cabbie named Moe is the closest Cranston has to a confidante, and he drives the Shadow wherever he needs to go. Alfred Pennyworth acts as Wayne’s chauffer, butler, confidante, and much more.

Call for Help

Cranston gets caught in a water trap and saved by a friend.Water almost proves the hero’s downfall until he calls for help. The Shadow tracks down one of Khan’s henchmen to an empty water tank. The henchman starts to fill the tank and spots the Shadow’s footprints in the water, shooting him. He then locks him in the tank and the Shadow psychically calls for help, which arrives in the nick of time. Batman tracks down the Scarecrow, but he leaves the window open and the rain pouring in alerts Scarecrow to Batman’s presence. He shoots Batman with a dose of scare toxin and lights him on fire. Batman barely escapes by calling Alfred and others to save him.

“You Never Learned”

Khan takes Cranston to task for not learning to control a certain magical sword.The hero is berated by the villain for never learning a key lesson in his training. Khan takes Cranston to task for not learning to control a magical sword, but at the climax of the film, Cranston finally figures it out and uses it to beat Khan. Ducard/Ra’s Al Ghul mocks Wayne for not learning to mind his surroundings during a fight. However, Wayne turns that criticism back on him during the film’s climax when he finds a way to defeat the villain’s plan.

The Evil Plan

Khan intends to detonate a nuclear bomb in the heart of New York City.With the aid of a weapon of mass destruction, the villain plans to wipe a large city off the map. Khan intends to detonate a nuclear bomb in the heart of New York City to assert his dominance as the successor to the conqueror, Genghis Khan. His plan is thwarted when the Shadow takes him on while the Shadow’s friends disarm the bomb. Al Ghul’s plan is to destroy Gotham City with scare toxin. He hints that he’s been destroying cities for two millennia. His plan is thwarted when Batman fights him head-on while his friends inoculate the city’s inhabitants to the toxin and prevent a device from causing citywide destruction.

Conclusion

It’s fitting that the Dark Knight should have so much in common with the Shadow. Batman Begins and The Shadow were made by innovative filmmakers (Christopher Nolan and Russell Mulcahy, respectively) who had proven themselves as unique visionaries with their debut films: Memento and Highlander, respectively.

It’s not a slight against Batman Begins to say that its plot closely resembles The Shadow’s. In my opinion, The Shadow is one of the better movies in the comic-book genre and its ending is nothing short of pure genius. Batman Begins is a good film, too. It set a lot of groundwork for the even-better The Dark Knight, and it showed what Nolan could do with a big budget.

Who knows what evil lurks in the hearts of men?  The Shadow knows.Did Nolan and David S. Goyer knowingly copy the plot of The Shadow for their innovative superhero movie? I don’t think so, but I suppose if anyone knows for sure, the Shadow knows.

This is the Deja Reviewer bidding you farewell until we meet again.

All images are the copyright of their respective owners.

Advertisements

About Robert Lockard, the Deja Reviewer

Robert Lockard has been a lover of writing since he was very young. He studied public relations in college, graduating with a Bachelor’s degree in 2006. His skills and knowledge have helped him to become a sought-after copywriter in the business world. He has written blogs, articles, and Web content on subjects such as real estate, online marketing and inventory management. His talent for making even boring topics interesting to read about has come in handy. But what he really loves to write about is movies. His favorite movies include: Fiddler on the Roof, Superman: The Movie, Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan, Back to the Future, Beauty and the Beast, The Fugitive, The Incredibles, and The Dark Knight. Check out his website: Deja Reviewer. Robert lives in Utah with his wife and three children. He loves running, biking, reading, and watching movies with his family.
This entry was posted in Movie Matchups and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Movie Matchups: Batman Begins vs. The Shadow (1994)

  1. Pingback: Top 10 Best Speeches in Christopher Nolan’s Dark Knight Trilogy | Deja Reviewer

  2. Yeah, but what about the Phantom?

    Like

  3. Nice take on two movies that I like.

    In terms of influence…well, THE SHADOW–the radio drama and original “pulp” stories–were influences on Batman’s creator, Bob Kane. Batman, after all, was created in 1939, when the era of pulp magazines was in full swing.

    Like

  4. Pingback: 10 Villains Who Think They Are Heroes | Deja Reviewer

  5. rgdole says:

    Had to tweet this… finally someone who recognizes how awesome The Shadow was… I love that movie… and everything about it was perfect… I feel like if it had come out now when comic book heroes are a big thing it would’ve done better… but who knows… sometimes people just don’t recognize real greatness…

    Like

  6. normanbf says:

    Las películas de Batman han sido magnificas, sin embargo creo que Batman Inicia ha sido mi preferida.

    Like

  7. Pingback: The Dynamic Do-Over | Deja Reviewer

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s