Movie Matchups: Star Trek V: The Final Frontier vs. Ghostbusters (1984)

I’m always on the lookout for seemingly disparate movies that have a lot in common. And I recently noticed that Star Trek V: The Final Frontier has many nearly identical setups as 1984’s Ghostbusters. I’m not saying that the makers of Star Trek V set out to rip off Ghostbusters or even pay homage to it. They simply made a lot of creative choices that went down a similar path as Ghostbusters, and they’re quite remarkable once you see them.

So let’s match up each of the scenes and ideas these two films have in common and see what they did with them.

Pre-Title Reveal

A librarian is scared by a ghost at the start of Ghostbusters.Ghostbusters begins with a pre-title sequence. In it, a librarian doing her usual rounds witnesses paranormal activities and she comes face to face with an off-screen ghost that causes her to scream her head off.

Sybok reveals himself to be an emotional Vulcan.Star Trek V was the first Star Trek film to start with a pre-title sequence. In it, a nomad digging holes in a desert comes face to face with a stranger who takes his inner pain away. Then the stranger reveals he is a Vulcan and he starts to laugh his head off.

Both of these films use their opening scene to reveal that something isn’t right. Ghostbusters is a comedy, but there’s nothing funny about an old woman being terrorized. It’s genuinely creepy and scary. And everyone knows that Vulcans are logical and devoid of emotion, so why is this Vulcan laughing like he’s in on some joke we’re not privy to? These are intriguing premises that invite the audience to wait for the answers.

A New Enterprise

The Ghostbusters move into a substandard firehouse.The nascent Ghostbusters are kicked out of their cushy jobs at a university and decide to start a business. They purchase an old firehouse as the home of their new enterprise, despite the fact that it has substandard electrical wiring and other major problems.

The Enterprise is catastrophically crippled in Star Trek V.Captain Kirk and his seasoned crewmates are called back from their vacation to embark on a new mission. Kirk returns to the newly christened Enterprise-A and discovers it’s in a hopeless state of disrepair.

The Ghostbusters demonstrate their competence by quickly turning the dilapidated firehouse into a state-of-the-art laser-protected holding grid for all sorts of ghosts. The Enterprise’s sorry state never improves much over the course of the film and is mostly used as an excuse for gags and plot convenience.

Cities Overrun

Ghosts overrun New York City in Ghostbusters.Ghosts overrun New York City, the symbol of American business and optimism. They terrorize many citizens, but they don’t appear to kill anyone. They’re just awaiting the coming of the godlike being Gozer.

Paradise City gets overrun by religious zealots.Religious zealots overrun Paradise City on Nimbus III, nicknamed the Planet of Galactic Peace because it is inhabited by humans, Romulans, and Klingons. The zealots take over the city, but they don’t have any desire to kill its inhabitants. They just want to attract a starship that can take them to their god.

The ghosts are actually threatening while the zealots mainly come across as a nuisance.

Possessed or Freed

People get possessed by demons in Ghostbusters..Two neighbors, Dana and Louis, get possessed by demons and are forced to act in bizarre ways that threaten to bring about the end of the world.

Kirk’s crewmates get freed from their personal demons and act in ways that are completely antithetical to their normal behavior. They help the villain bring the Enterprise to the center of the galaxy.

The Enterprise crew get freed from their inner demons.It’s shocking to see Dana’s no-nonsense demeanor transformed into a sensual display and it’s funny to see Louis acting even crazier than normal. But it’s completely unbelievable for Sulu, Chekov, and Uhura to turn on Captain Kirk, even if Sybok freed them from some deep pain they were hiding. They just wouldn’t do that. Thank goodness Spock and McCoy didn’t.

Prison Break

The Ghostbusters get sent to prison.After allowing an EPA official to shut off their protection grid, the Ghostbusters get arrested for supposedly causing a major environmental catastrophe. However, they are able to plead their case to the mayor and talk their way out of prison.

Kirk, Spock, and McCoy get sent to prison.After allowing Sybok and his men to get aboard the Enterprise, Kirk, Spock, and McCoy get put in the brig. They don’t talk their way out of prison, but they instead get busted out by Scotty.

I have to admit it’s pretty funny seeing Scotty going commando and trying to save the day. But it’s also extremely satisfying to see Peter Venkman put the EPA jerk in his place and win his freedom by appealing to the mayor’s self-interest.

The Long Climb

The Ghostbusters slowly make their way up two dozen flights of stairs.The Ghostbusters are forced to climb a long staircase in a high-rise building for two dozen floors to reach Dana’s apartment because the building’s elevators are out. They comically trudge their way up, carrying heavy proton packs and wishing for their misery to finally end.

Kirk, Spock, and McCoy must climb a ridiculously tall turboshaft.Kirk and McCoy begin to climb their way up an extremely high turboshaft. But before they make it very far they are met by a rocket-boot-powered Spock who takes them up dozens of decks and even overshoots the mark.

Ghostbusters manages to insert another brilliant joke into an otherwise serious situation while Spock pulls a Kobayashi Maru and cheats in order to creatively solve an impossible task.

Questioning God

Gozer shoots the Ghostbusters with lightning bolts.After Ray engages in a little bit of banter with a godlike being, Gozer asks him, “Are you a god?” Ray admits he isn’t one, and then Gozer proceeds to punish him by shooting him and the other Ghostbusters with lightning bolts from its fingertips and telling them to die. 

A being claiming to be God shoots Kirk for doubting him.After a being claiming to be God tells Sybok to bring the Enterprise closer, Kirk asks, “What does God need with a starship?” The being responds with a question of his own: “Do you doubt me?” Kirk says he demands proof that the being really is God, so the being shoots Kirk with lightning from his eyes.

The lesson is you should be careful when dealing with someone who claims to be a god. If you can’t outwit them, at least try to duck.

Ineffective Counterattack

The Ghostbusters fight back with energy blasts from their proton packs. Gozer disappears before they can strike and capture it. But Gozer soon reappears in a new form.

Kirk orders the Enterprise to fire a proton torpedo at the alien being. At first it looks like it’s destroyed, but it soon resurfaces in a modified version of its old form.

The good guys’ counterattack isn’t as effective as they would have liked.

Choose the Destructor

Ray chooses the Stay Puft Marshmallow Man for Gozer's final form.Gozer’s final form is chosen by one of the Ghostbusters. After being commanded to choose and perish, Ray accidentally thinks of his most beloved corporate mascot from his childhood: The Stay Puft Marshmallow Man. And right on cue, a hundred-foot-tall evil version of Mr. Stay Puft shows up and begins to rain destruction on New York City.

The godlike being chooses Sybok as its final form.The being that Sybok thought was God turns out to be an evil alien. It takes on the form of Sybok to mock his naïve pursuit of God. The Sybok lookalike then threatens to kill Sybok, Kirk, Spock, and McCoy if they don’t accede to his wishes.

We make our own monsters. The things these characters thought were pure and innocent turn out to be just as corruptible as anything else.

Crossing Streams and Timely Beams

Winston is grateful to be alive after defeating Gozer.Expecting to die, the Ghostbusters agree to cross their streams in order to generate enough power to close the dimensional portal and send Gozer back to wherever it came from. Thankfully, they all miraculously survive the ensuing explosion and are ecstatic to still be alive.

Kirk gets emotional after Spock saves his life.Expecting to die alone, Kirk has Spock and McCoy beamed off the planet so he can face off with the alien being by himself. However, a Klingon Bird of Prey shows up and blasts the being to kingdom come. Kirk becomes emotional when he learns that Spock fired the shot that saved his life.

This moment is set up early in both films when Egon tells the other Ghostbusters not to cross the streams and when Kirk tells Spock and McCoy he intends to die alone. It’s a great payoff in both cases.

We’re Ready to Believe You

Ghostbusters was a reaction to The Exorcist and other occult films and obsessions in pop culture at the time while Star Trek V was a reaction to TV evangelist hucksters taking advantage of well-meaning but gullible believers. They approached the topic of religion from different angles and found quite a bit in common, though with disparate levels of success.

Star Trek V was trying to be a comedy while also grappling with deep questions of God, religious devotion, and personal belief. Somehow, it didn’t quite gel into a good movie. But Ghostbusters showed that it’s not necessarily a bad idea to insert cosmic questions about God into a comical film. In fact, it makes it look so effortless that one can forget what a precarious balancing act that film pulled off. Believe me, it’s not easy.

This is the Deja Reviewer bidding you farewell until we meet again.

All images are the copyright of their respective owners.

Advertisements

About Robert Lockard, the Deja Reviewer

Robert Lockard has been a lover of writing since he was very young. He studied public relations in college, graduating with a Bachelor’s degree in 2006. His skills and knowledge have helped him to become a sought-after copywriter in the business world. He has written blogs, articles, and Web content on subjects such as real estate, online marketing and inventory management. His talent for making even boring topics interesting to read about has come in handy. But what he really loves to write about is movies. His favorite movies include: Fiddler on the Roof, Superman: The Movie, Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan, Back to the Future, Beauty and the Beast, The Fugitive, The Incredibles, and The Dark Knight. Check out his website: Deja Reviewer. Robert lives in Utah with his wife and three children. He loves running, biking, reading, and watching movies with his family.
This entry was posted in Movie Matchups and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Movie Matchups: Star Trek V: The Final Frontier vs. Ghostbusters (1984)

  1. Dave says:

    So insightful! Great, Robert!

    Like

  2. Kevin Noble says:

    I have to agree. I am glad someone else noticed. The plots are similar. The ending with the gargoyles in Ghostbusters made me wish Trumbull had come back to do the FX for Trek V. But after ILM got Trek II that was not going to happen.

    Like

  3. Pingback: The Right Way and the Wrong Way to Do a One-Joke Comedy | Deja Reviewer

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s