I compared Fiddler on the Roof and Pride and Prejudice a little while back, and I found them to be surprisingly similar in their stories and characters. Two characters, in particular, kept coming to my mind and I decided that they deserve special attention. The characters are the fathers of their respective families: Tevye and Mr. Bennet.
Tevye wishes he was rich. He spends so much time yearning for what he doesn’t have that he misses the fact that he is so happy simply being a poor milkman. Mr. Bennet has everything that Tevye dreams of. He is fabulously wealthy, he never has to work for his money, and he can live in comfort all his days. And yet he is hopelessly miserable. It turns out that Tevye would be better off where he is and he shouldn’t bother envying the rich because money wouldn’t solve his problems.
There’s a whole song dedicated to Tevye’s wish to be wealthy, “If I Were a Rich Man.” And I’m going to go through it basically line by line and show how everything Tevye wants, Mr. Bennet has received and it hasn’t made him happy at all. At the start, Tevye asks “What would have been so terrible if I had a small fortune?” I’m here to explain exactly how terrible it would have been.
And there might just be a lesson in this for all of us.
I’ll share the lyrics of the song in italics and then give my commentary on each verse beneath them. Continue reading →